Why Choosing The Right Type of Test Soil Matters in Medical Device Reprocessing Validation
Building Confidence in Cleaning Validation with the Right Test Soil
Reusable medical devices have a critical role in the healthcare sector. Every time a medical device has been used, it is exposed to blood, tissue, and other biological contaminants during clinical use and if these contaminants are not effectively removed during reprocessing, there is a serious risk of infection transmission between patients.
This is why cleaning validation is such an essential part of reprocessing validation for reusable medical devices and at the heart of effective cleaning validation lies one often-overlooked factor: the selection of the correct testing soil.
Author:
Carol Davies
Carol has 17 years of experience across validation, quality control, sample management, and sterility operations. She currently works within the Sterility department at Cormica’s Wickham Micro site.
Share with your colleagues:
The Hidden Risk of Improper Reprocessing
Medical devices such as endoscopes, arthroscopic shavers, surgical instruments, and suction tubing often contain internal channels, making them particularly challenging to clean. If cleaning is not properly validated, residual soil can remain on the device and potentially allow biofilm microorganisms to form, even after disinfection or sterilisation, compromising patient safety.
What Is Test Soil and Why Is It Important?
Test soils are specially designed materials used during cleaning validation to simulate clinical contamination. Their purpose is to challenge the cleaning process and demonstrate that the manufacturer’s instructions are effective. Selecting the correct test soil ensures that validation results are:
- Clinically relevant
- Reproducible
- Scientifically defensible
- Aligned with regulatory expectations
Without an appropriate test soil, even a well-designed validation study can fail to represent real-world use.
What Makes An Effective Test Soil?
A well-chosen test soil should:
- Mimic contaminants encountered during actual clinical use
- Represent residues that are difficult to remove
- Be standardised to allow repeatable and comparable results
- Be scientifically justified if modified from standard formulations
Using standardised soils helps ensure consistency across studies and supports compliance with international standards and regulatory guidance.
Commonly Used Test Soils
Different devices require different soiling challenges, for example:
- Blood-based soils, often used for surgical instruments
- Artificial saliva or mucus soils, relevant for endoscopes
- Bone or bone marrow–based soils, used for orthopaedic devices
A combination of test soils maybe be used e.g. blood with mucus; however, mixtures of different soils can be made depending on how the device is contaminated during the clinical procedure.
When selecting a test soil, it is important to consider how and where the device is used so that the soil accurately represents real-world contaminants.
Final Thoughts: Small Decisions, Big Impact
Choosing the correct test soil may seem like a small detail, but it has a significant impact on the validity of cleaning studies and ultimately on patient safety. Meaningful reprocessing validation starts with realistic challenges that reflect real clinical conditions. When test soils are selected thoughtfully and applied consistently, healthcare providers and manufacturers can be confident that their reprocessing validation methods truly protect patients.
Other Cormica News, Events & Resources
Cormica's Webinars
Recent News
Technical Resources
Laboratories near you, supporting global product success
With accredited laboratories in the UK, EU and US, we support pharmaceutical, medical device and combination product manufacturers worldwide. Local support combined with global quality, delivered by teams who understand your regulatory requirements.
Our Clients’ Experiences
